Natural vs. Lab-Grown Diamonds & Gemstones: Understanding the Difference
In today's world of fine jewelry, few topics spark more curiosity than the difference between natural and lab-grown (synthetic) diamonds as well as colored gemstones. At first glance, they may look identical, both dazzling, brilliant, and durable, but their origins, rarity, and long-term value tell two very different stories.
1. What Are Natural Diamonds?
Natural diamonds are formed deep within the Earth’s mantle under extreme heat and pressure. Over billions of years, carbon atoms bond in a crystal structure that creates the hardest natural material known to man. Volcanic activity then brings these gems closer to the Earth’s surface, where they are mined.
- Origin: Formed naturally over 1-3 billion years.
- Rarity: Scarce, making them more valuable and collectible.
- Value Retention: Historically strong resale and heirloom value.
2. What Are Lab-Grown (Synthetic) Diamonds?
A synthetic diamond has all the same physically, and optically of a natural one, but it was grown in a laboratory - that's where the term Lab-Grown to describe synthetic diamonds is from - rather than by nature (source: GIA).
Two known processes used to grow gem-quality synthetic diamonds are : HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature) and CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition).
- Origin: Created in weeks or months under high-tech processes.
- Appearance: Visually identical to natural diamonds (in most cases, even experts need specialized equipment to detect origin).
- Value: More affordable but generally has little to no resale value compared to natural diamonds.
3. Key Differences at a Glance
|
Feature |
Natural Diamond |
Lab-Grown Diamond |
|---|---|---|
|
Formation Time |
1–3 billion years |
Weeks to months |
|
Origin |
Earth’s mantle |
Laboratory/Factory |
|
Rarity |
Rare to very rare |
Can be produced unlimitedly |
|
Value Retention |
Strong long-term |
Limited resale value |
|
Environmental Impact |
Mining footprint |
High energy-intensive but no mining |
4. What About Other Gemstones?
The natural vs. synthetic story doesn’t end with diamonds, many colored gemstones also have man-created counterparts. We will focus on the big 3 that are Ruby, Sapphire & Emerald.
- Ruby: Natural rubies form deep underground and are prized for their rich red color and rarity. Synthetic rubies are identical in composition but can be produced without inclusions or imperfections. They are often used in both jewelry and industrial applications (mechanical watches movements).
- Sapphire: Natural sapphires (blue, pink, yellow, and pretty much all the colors of the rainbow) are formed over millions of years in the Earth. Synthetic sapphires share the same corundum structure and brilliance, often used in both jewelry and industrial applications (sapphire glass).
- Emerald: Natural emeralds, known for their vivid green color, often contain unique inclusions called “jardin” Synthetic emeralds replicate the same beryl structure and color but can appear cleaner and more uniform.
Just like with diamonds, natural colored gemstones generally command higher value due to their rarity, while man-created versions offer a more affordable, and accessible alternative.
5. Choosing What’s Right for You
The decision between natural and lab-grown gems comes down to priorities:
- If you value rarity, long-term investment, and the romance of a gem formed over eons, natural stones are the way to go.
- If you want maximum size and brilliance for your budget, and don't mind the synthetic origin, lab-grown gems are an excellent choice. Just keep in mind that they have very little resale value.
Whether you’re buying a diamond engagement ring or a vibrant colored gemstone, understanding these differences helps you make a choice that’s as timeless as the jewelry you’ll wear.
See what our customers said
